Caught Red-Handed: Why Is the Former Owner's Friend Still Fishing in Your Pond? Can It Be Stopped

Let’s dive into the legal side of this surprising (and surprisingly common) situation.

  • The Sokoler Team
  • May 5, 2025

Caught Red-Handed: Why Is the Former Owner’s Friend Still Fishing in Your Pond — and Can You Stop Them?

You’ve finally closed on your dream home complete with a beautiful private pond. But just when you’re settling in, you spot someone casting a line like it’s still/their secret fishing hole.

Turns out, it’s the former owner’s buddy, and he never got the memo that the property has changed hands. So, what now? Can you legally stop him? The short answer: Yes — In most cases, absolutely.

Let’s dive into the legal side of this surprising (and surprisingly common) situation.

Who Owns the Pond Now?

If the pond is entirely on your property, then you own it, plain and simple. That includes the land beneath the water and the right to control access to it.

If the pond straddles a property line or is part of a shared waterways/things get a bit trickier — shared-use agreements or easements may apply, and you’ll want to check the deed and title documents to confirm ownership and usage rights.

Did the Former Owner Grant Permission?

Sometimes, former owners casually allow friends or neighbors to fish, hunt, or hike on the land… but unless those rights were formally recorded (like in a written easement), that permission usually ends the moment the property changes hands.

In Kentucky and most states, verbal agreements made by previous owners aren’t binding after a sale.

What If He’s Been Fishing There for Years?

You might hear someone argue, “I’ve been fishing here for 20 years!” But even long-time use doesn’t automatically make it legal.

To establish a prescriptive easement (think: long-term use rights similar to squatter’s rights), someone would have to prove continuous, open, and hostile use of the property for a legally defined period — often 15-20 years — and without the owner’s permission. That’s a high legal bar and rarely applies to recreational uses like fishing.

Trespassing Is Still Trespassing

Bottom line: if they’re on your land without permission, they’re trespassing. Kentucky law protects private landowners from unauthorized use — even if the trespasser thinks they have a tradition or “right” to be there.

Here’s what you can do:

  • Politely ask them to leave (and not return).
  • Post clear “No Trespassing” signs around your pond and property line.
  • Document each incident with photos or notes.
  • If it continues, call local law enforcement or consult an attorney.
  • You may also pursue a civil injunction to legally bar the person from returning.

Final Thoughts

Owning land means you get to decide who uses it,  including your pond. While it’s awkward to tell someone they no longer have access, your legal rights as a property owner are clear.

So yes, you can stop the fishing,  and you should, if it makes you uncomfortable or puts your property value, liability, or peace of mind at risk.

Work With Us

Bob Sokoler's years as an Emmy-winning journalist taught The Sokoler Team to ask sharp questions and explain the details clearly. Let us put that same care into presenting your home and planning your next move.