Can Sellers Really Require You to Use Their Title Company? Here's What You Need to Know

When buying a home, you’ll encounter many decisions—one of them being which title company to us

  • The Sokoler Team
  • March 20, 2025

Can Sellers REALLY Require You to Use Their Title Company? Here’s What You Need to Know

When buying a home, you’ll encounter many decisions, one of them being which title company to use. Some sellers insist you use their preferred title company, but can they actually require it? The short answer: it depends on who’s paying for title insurance.

Your Rights as a Buyer

Under the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA), if you, the buyer, are paying for the owner’s title insurance, you have the right to choose your own title company. The seller cannot legally require you to use theirs.

However, if the seller is covering the title insurance cost, they have the right to select the title company since they’re paying for it. This is common in many markets and not considered a violation of RESPA.

New Construction & Builder Contracts

Many builders offer closing cost incentives but only if you agree to use their title company. While this is legal under RESPA, the “incentive” should be a legitimate discount rather than a penalty for choosing your own company.

What If a Seller Insists?

  • Negotiate: You can always request to use your preferred title company.
  • Get Legal Advice: If you feel pressured or unsure, consult your real estate agent or attorney.
  • Report Violations: If a seller improperly demands you use their title company when you should have a choice, it may be a RESPA violation.

Bottom Line

Sellers cannot force you to use a specific title company unless they’re paying for the title insurance. Always know your rights, negotiate when needed, and ensure you’re working with a title company that protects your best interests.

Work With Us

Bob Sokoler's years as an Emmy-winning journalist taught The Sokoler Team to ask sharp questions and explain the details clearly. Let us put that same care into presenting your home and planning your next move.